Amber Brown Is Not a Crayon

by Paula Danziger, Victoria Ying

Third grader Amber Brown and her best friend, Justin Daniels, do almost everything together, so Justin’s upcoming move leaves Amber angry, worried, and unsure how to say goodbye. With humor and a candid child’s perspective, the story explores how friendship can survive hurt feelings, change, and distance.

Big Idea

Change can make people act angry when they actually feel hurt or afraid. Naming those feelings and listening to another person’s perspective can help friends face difficult transitions.

Discussion Questions

1.What does Amber want Justin to understand about his move? What might Justin want Amber to understand?
2.How do Amber’s words and actions reveal feelings she does not always name directly?
3.When does humor help Amber handle a difficult situation? When might joking make it harder to communicate?
4.What makes Amber and Justin’s friendship special? Which details show that they know each other well?
5.How does Amber’s understanding of saying goodbye change? What evidence suggests that a friendship can change without becoming unimportant?

Lesson Plan

⏱ 45 minutes📦 Copies of the book or selected excerpts, paper, pencils, crayons or colored pencils, and a board or chart paper. Optional: sticky notes and a document camera.

Learning Goals

Explain how Amber’s feelings about Justin’s move influence her words and actions, using story evidence.
Consider Amber’s and Justin’s different perspectives on the same change.
Distinguish between a scene that develops a moment and a summary that moves quickly through time.
Write a short narrative that uses dialogue, details, and a purposeful pause to control pacing.
Read writing aloud and revise one place where the pace does not match the intended feeling.

Activity Steps

1.Discuss and model, 7 minutes: Revisit an exchange about Justin’s move. Identify what a character says, what the character does, and what those clues suggest about an unspoken feeling.
2.Plan, 6 minutes: Fold paper into four sections labeled Before, The News, The Pause, and The Next Step. Plan an imagined Amber-and-Justin scene or a fictional scene about friends facing change.
3.Draft, 12 minutes: Write the first three sections. Include dialogue, an ordinary friendship detail, and a small action that slows the most emotional moment. Drawings may support, but should not replace, the writing goal.
4.Move time forward, 5 minutes: In the fourth section, write one or two sentences summarizing what happens later. Add a realistic next step rather than a solution that erases every difficult feeling.
5.Partner-read and revise, 10 minutes: Partners read aloud, identify the slowest moment, and explain its effect. Writers revise one sentence, dialogue break, or detail to make the emotional pacing clearer.
6.Reflect, 5 minutes: Share selected examples and complete the exit statement: “I slowed the story when ___ because ___.” Distinguish invented scenes from events in the book.

Standards Connections

ELA: RL.3.3 — Describe characters and explain how their actions contribute to the sequence of events; adapt complexity for grades 2–6.
ELA: W.3.3 — Write narratives using descriptive details, dialogue, and a clear sequence of events.
ELA: SL.3.1 — Participate in collaborative discussions, building on others’ ideas and explaining one’s own thinking.
SEL: Self-awareness and relationship skills — Identify mixed emotions, consider another perspective, and practice constructive communication.
Visual literacy: Analyze how illustrations or sequential images communicate emotion and the passage of time, especially when using Victoria Ying’s graphic adaptation.

Pace-Write-Read Study with Pace-Write It!

Amber Brown Is Not a Crayon makes a familiar childhood problem—having a best friend move away—feel immediate through Amber’s distinctive voice. Her humor, opinions, and attention to everyday experiences keep readers close to her, while the approaching separation gives ordinary interactions greater emotional weight. Students can study how a story moves forward through both outward events and changes in what a character is ready to admit. In a Pace-Write-Read study, students first notice where reading feels quick and where a moment invites them to linger. They then write a short scene, making deliberate choices about dialogue, details, pauses, and summary, and read it aloud to test those choices. Use the prose edition to examine sentences and paragraphs; if using Victoria Ying’s graphic adaptation, also examine panels, expressions, and spaces between images. Compare effects without assuming that the two editions arrange every moment identically. Keep the central craft question visible: “How much reading time does this feeling need?” Younger writers can develop one exchange with a spoken line and a revealing action; older writers can contrast a character’s outward words with inward feelings and explain why they expanded one moment while compressing another.

Element	How to notice or teach it in the novel
1. Pacing	Compare a routine school or friendship passage with an emotionally important exchange about Justin’s move. Ask where the storytelling lingers and how that extra attention helps readers understand Amber.
2. Plot	Map the central progression: an established friendship, an approaching move, conflict over the change, and movement toward saying goodbye. Separate what happens from how Amber’s response develops.
3. Prosody	Read a brief humorous passage and a tense exchange aloud, adjusting stress, phrasing, and pauses to fit Amber’s feelings. Ask students to justify their choices using wording and punctuation rather than simply reading louder.
4. Word	Collect words that make Amber sound like a particular child rather than an adult narrator. Try replacing one expressive word with a neutral alternative and discuss what happens to voice and reading speed.
5. Concept	Distinguish the situation—Justin is moving—from the larger concept of friendship under pressure. Invite students to show that concept through a small disagreement rather than explaining a moral.
6. Voice & Worldview	Notice how Amber’s humor and strong opinions shape the way readers encounter her world. Discuss how something that seems manageable to an adult can feel enormous from Amber’s perspective.
7. Point of View	In the prose narrative, Amber’s first-person perspective gives readers direct access to her thinking but not Justin’s. Rewrite a short moment from Justin’s perspective, clearly labeling his invented thoughts as inference rather than fact.
8. Setting & Place	Track how familiar school and home settings establish the everyday closeness of Amber and Justin’s friendship. Ask why the prospect of not sharing those places makes the move more painful.
9. Original Characters	Identify details that make Amber more than simply “a sad friend,” including her humor, preferences, and contradictions. Have students give an invented character both a specific habit and a complicated feeling.
10. Dialogue	Study an exchange in which Amber and Justin’s spoken words do not fully explain their feelings. Add a brief action between invented dialogue lines to show hesitation without explaining everything.
11. Details	Find an ordinary detail that demonstrates how well Amber and Justin know each other. Discuss why a shared habit or familiar possession can make separation more convincing than a general statement about sadness.
12. Descriptions	Notice which descriptions help readers understand Amber’s experience and which parts move quickly without extended description. Practice describing one relevant action or expression instead of stopping the scene for a full inventory.
13. Firsts	Treat the opening as readers’ first encounter with Amber: what establishes her personality and her friendship with Justin? Students can draft an opening that introduces a relationship through action rather than background explanation.
14. Immediacy & Engagement	Ask how Amber’s candid reactions make readers feel close to a third grader’s present concerns. Compare an immediate scene with a distant explanation of the same problem.
15. Story Scenes, Summaries & Structures	Mark a passage that stages an interaction and another that summarizes information or passing time. Explain why a difficult conversation deserves more space than every ordinary event surrounding it.
16. Tension / Suspense / Surprise	Frame the central suspense as a relationship question: how will Amber and Justin handle the separation? Track how avoidance or disagreement delays the conversation readers hope they will have.
17. Flashback, Flash-Forward, Cliffhanger	Distinguish references to earlier friendship experiences from worries about the future; neither automatically constitutes a full flashback or flash-forward. Examine whether a selected section leaves an emotional question unresolved rather than assuming every ending is a cliffhanger.
18. Page Turns and Chapter Breaks	Inspect an actual chapter ending or, in Ying’s adaptation, a page turn: what question or feeling carries readers onward? Explain that pagination and break placement can differ across editions.
19. Pace & Creativity	Write the same invented move-related exchange twice: once in three sentences and once as a developed scene. Compare which version better reveals Amber-like mixed feelings and why.
20. Play	Use the title’s connection between Amber’s name and a color as an entry point into playful language and identity. Invite students to invent a harmless name-based misunderstanding for a fictional character, not tease classmates.
21. Performance	Perform a short exchange with different pauses and emphasis to explore possible emotions beneath the words. Keep performances grounded in the text and discuss which interpretation has stronger evidence.
22. Personality	Track how Amber’s personality remains recognizable when her mood changes. Ask students to preserve a character’s distinctive way of speaking in both a funny moment and a difficult one.
23. Humor	Notice how Amber’s observations allow humor and hurt to coexist. Discuss whether a funny moment releases tension, reveals personality, or briefly postpones a harder conversation.
24. Pause	Look for a place where a reaction, action, or visual beat delays the next response. Students can insert one meaningful pause before a fictional friend answers news about a move.
25. Poetry / Poetic Devices	Begin with the title’s play on Amber Brown’s name, then look for comparisons or sound patterns in the selected text. Do not assume the book is poetry; discuss how a prose writer can use concentrated language for effect.
26. Repetition	Track repeated references to the move or to friendship and ask whether their emotional meaning changes. Writers can repeat a short phrase twice, letting the second use reveal a changed understanding.
27. Rhythm	Compare the rhythm of quick back-and-forth talk with a passage of Amber’s reflection. Read both aloud to hear how sentence length and conversational turns affect momentum.
28. Punctuation	Examine how the punctuation in a selected passage guides Amber’s delivery and emotional emphasis. Revise an invented line using different sentence boundaries, then compare the resulting pace without changing its basic meaning.
29. Questions	Identify questions characters ask and questions readers carry about the friendship. Discuss how an unanswered emotional question can sustain interest even when the fact of Justin’s move is already known.
30. Compare-Contrast	Compare Amber’s and Justin’s responses to the move using separate evidence for each. Ask how different reactions to the same loss can produce conflict without making either friend a villain.
31. Objects	Choose an object actually present in your selected passage and discuss its practical or emotional role. In writing, give friends an ordinary shared object that becomes meaningful because one person is leaving.
32. Threes	Check whether a selected passage groups actions or details in threes; treat this as an observation, not a presumed pattern. As an experiment, write three brief actions before a goodbye and test whether they build anticipation.
33. Lists	Look for any listing in Amber’s narration and consider whether it conveys enthusiasm, frustration, or speed. If none appears in the excerpt, students can invent a clearly labeled list of things a fictional friend would miss.
34. White Space & Negative Space	In prose, examine paragraph breaks around dialogue; in the graphic adaptation, examine gutters and less crowded panels. Ask how these spaces separate responses or invite readers to linger, without assigning every blank area a fixed meaning.
35. Art & Graphics	In Victoria Ying’s adaptation, study how expressions, posture, and panel sequences communicate Amber’s feelings alongside words. With a prose edition, use its available illustrations or have students storyboard an excerpt and justify their visual choices.
36. Interactives & Gamification	Use teacher-created “pace detective” cards to locate a quick exchange, a lingering reaction, and a time jump. These are classroom tools, not features claimed to be part of the book.
37. Placement	Ask why readers need to understand Amber and Justin’s closeness before fully feeling the threat of separation. Experiment with moving a friendship detail before or after difficult news and compare its impact.
38. Form	Compare how a prose scene and a graphic sequence can present the same friendship problem through different combinations of narration, dialogue, and images. Discuss how form changes readers’ work without requiring a different central theme.
39. Dummy	Make a rough four-page booklet, or dummy, of an invented friendship scene inspired by Amber and Justin. Move dialogue and images between pages to test where a pause or page turn best supports the emotion.
40. Passion	Identify what Amber cares about deeply and how that investment gives an ordinary childhood event narrative force. Invite students to write about something a fictional character genuinely values, without requiring personal stories of loss.

Pace-Write It!

20-minute Pace-Write-It! task — “Before Justin Answers.” Minutes 0–3: Revisit a brief exchange connected to Justin’s move and identify what Amber says versus what she may feel. Minutes 3–5: Plan an imagined additional exchange, clearly labeled as student-created rather than a missing scene from the book. Minutes 5–11: Write 6–10 sentences from Amber’s first-person perspective, using two lines of dialogue, one specific friendship detail, and one small action that slows the moment before Justin answers. Aim for candid, child-centered language without copying the author’s sentences. Minutes 11–13: Add one sentence that moves time forward, such as a transition to the next school day. Minutes 13–17: Read to a partner, who identifies the deliberate pause and the time jump. Minutes 17–20: Revise one pacing choice and finish: “I gave this moment more space because ___.” Younger students may dictate or combine drawings with captions; older students should let words and actions suggest a feeling they do not name directly.

Classroom Activities

The Goodbye That Takes Its Time

Students create a folded, four-part friendship scene inspired by Amber and Justin’s difficulty facing his move. They use dialogue, small actions, and optional drawings to slow down an important emotional moment, then use a brief summary to move time forward. Students may write about the book’s characters or invent a fictional friendship; personal disclosures are not required.

Create a free account to reveal this guide

Your free account includes one complete guide download — the full teacher’s guide, discussion questions, classroom activities, and the Pace-Write-Read writing workshop.

Create Free Account Sign in

Discussion questions PWR workshop PDF download