Dust

by Alison Stine

In Alison Stine’s young adult novel Dust, Thea, a teenager with hearing loss, moves with her family to an isolated Colorado homestead, where their dream of self-sufficiency collides with drought, dust, and growing instability. As she develops connections beyond her family and gains access to sign language, Thea begins to challenge the limits others have placed on her communication, independence, and future.

Big Idea

Being heard depends not only on speaking but also on having access, recognition, and people willing to listen. Dust connects a teenager’s struggle for autonomy with questions about environmental responsibility, family authority, and the communities people need to survive.

Discussion Questions

1.How does the family’s homesteading dream differ from Thea’s experience of living in Colorado? What does that difference reveal about who gets to define a successful life?
2.When does isolation function as protection, and when does it become a form of control? Trace how your answer changes as Thea develops relationships outside her family.
3.How do access to communication and other people’s responses to Thea’s hearing loss influence her choices? Identify moments when the barrier lies in her surroundings rather than in Thea herself.
4.How does Stine make dust and drought more than background conditions? Discuss how the environment affects conflict, mood, and the possibilities characters can imagine.
5.Where does Stine slow the narrative to help readers understand Thea, and where does she accelerate it? How do those choices shape our judgments about Thea’s family and her growing independence?

Lesson Plan

⏱ 50 minutes📦 Copies of Dust, a teacher-selected excerpt, paper, pencils, highlighters or colored pencils, and optional sticky notes or a shared digital document. Provide accessible digital text and written discussion directions as needed.

Learning Goals

Cite precise textual evidence to explain how environmental conditions and communication barriers shape Thea’s choices.
Analyze how sentence length, paragraph breaks, dialogue, and reflection influence narrative pace.
Distinguish between a character’s disability and barriers created by attitudes, environments, or inaccessible communication.
Revise an original scene to create two different pacing effects while preserving its central action.
Explain how a specific craft choice connects to a theme of autonomy, belonging, or environmental vulnerability.

Activity Steps

1.Establish context and access norms (5 minutes): Review Thea’s move to Colorado and the pressures surrounding her hearing loss, family life, and isolation. Explain that students will study narrative access, not simulate deafness or hearing loss.
2.Annotate a passage (10 minutes): Read a teacher-selected excerpt from students’ current reading. Mark action, dialogue, sensory detail, reflection, and paragraph breaks; identify where the pace seems to change.
3.Build a pacing map (8 minutes): In pairs, draw a line showing perceived speed across the excerpt. Attach at least three brief quotations or textual references explaining rises, slowdowns, or pauses.
4.Write contrasting versions (12 minutes): Draft an original 100–150-word scene about a teenager deciding whether to ask someone for help in a dry, unfamiliar landscape. Rewrite it at a distinctly different pace without changing the central decision.
5.Compare and revise (10 minutes): Exchange drafts. Partners identify two craft choices that change pace and discuss whether the narrator’s access to information remains consistent. Writers revise one paragraph.
6.Reflect (5 minutes): Submit the pacing map and an exit ticket explaining how one pacing choice in Dust supports a theme and how that choice informed the student’s revision.

Standards Connections

CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RL.9-10.1 / RL.11-12.1: Cite strong and thorough textual evidence to support literary analysis.
CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RL.9-10.5: Analyze how structure, event order, and manipulation of time create effects such as tension and surprise.
CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RL.11-12.5: Analyze how an author’s choices about structuring a text contribute to its overall meaning and aesthetic impact.
CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.W.9-10.3 / W.11-12.3: Write narratives using effective technique, well-chosen details, and structured event sequences.
CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.SL.9-10.1 / SL.11-12.1: Participate effectively in collaborative discussions, building on others’ ideas and expressing interpretations clearly.

Pace-Write-Read Study with Pace-Write It!

Alison Stine’s Dust offers a way to study pacing as more than the speed of a plot. Thea’s move to an isolated Colorado homestead places her within overlapping pressures: a damaged environment, a family’s expectations, and uneven access to communication. Readers can investigate how stretches of observation, uncertainty, conversation, and decision-making produce different experiences of time. A moment that appears uneventful from outside may be intensely consequential for Thea. For a Pace-Write-Read study, students should follow a repeatable cycle: read a short passage, identify its craft choices, imitate one technique in original writing, and reread to assess the effect. Pay particular attention to how Stine filters information through Thea’s experience rather than assuming that every character receives the same information at the same time. Examine visual, tactile, and environmental details alongside language and dialogue; hearing should not be treated as the default measure of a fully realized scene. The workshop’s central question is: How does a writer control the reader’s access to experience? Students can test how a paragraph break delays recognition, how a compressed summary makes hardship accumulate, or how a pause allows a relationship to change. The guidance below offers investigations rather than claims that every listed device occurs prominently in the novel; where a feature is absent or edition-dependent, students should treat it as a deliberate adaptation exercise.

Element	How to notice or teach it in the novel
1. Pacing	Compare a passage about daily life on the homestead with a moment of interpersonal pressure or decision. Track how action, reflection, and sentence boundaries make Thea’s experience feel prolonged, compressed, or urgent.
2. Plot	Map how the move to Colorado, the difficulties of homesteading, and Thea’s relationships beyond her family create new choices. Distinguish events that merely happen from events that change what she can do next.
3. Prosody	Study the phrasing and cadence of a descriptive passage, marking emphasis and pauses. Offer oral reading, silent annotation, or visual phrase grouping as equally valid ways to investigate the prose’s movement.
4. Word	Collect exact words Stine uses for the dry landscape and for Thea’s interactions with others. Test how replacing one precise verb or adjective with a general term changes intensity and reading speed.
5. Concept	Explore the contradiction between seeking freedom through isolation and becoming dependent on an unforgiving environment. Ask how that central concept generates both the family conflict and Thea’s search for connection.
6. Voice & Worldview	Identify language that reveals Thea’s judgments about her family’s plans and her own possibilities. Separate her evolving worldview from any assumption that the novel speaks for all deaf or hard-of-hearing people.
7. Point of View	Track what readers learn through Thea’s perspective and what remains uncertain about other characters’ motives. Discuss how staying close to her knowledge shapes sympathy and delays interpretation.
8. Setting & Place	Map the isolated homestead and the spaces where Thea encounters a wider community. Explain how distance, drought, and dust affect movement, relationships, and the pace of daily life.
9. Original Characters	Build a character profile for Thea using her desires, judgments, relationships, and decisions—not only her hearing loss. Examine how those intersecting qualities keep her from becoming merely a symbol of isolation.
10. Dialogue	Annotate an exchange for what is communicated, what is missed, and what characters assume has been understood. Where sign language appears, examine how Stine represents that interaction without treating signed communication as less complete than speech.
11. Details	Choose three small details from a homestead passage that reveal practical hardship or family dynamics. Explain how each detail conveys information that a broad statement such as 'life was difficult' would lose.
12. Descriptions	Examine how descriptions of dust and dryness work alongside Thea’s immediate concerns. Test whether shortening one description increases urgency but removes emotional or environmental context.
13. Firsts	Locate an early experience that expands Thea’s access to communication, connection, or independence. Study how much narrative space Stine gives the moment and why its significance may exceed its outward action.
14. Immediacy & Engagement	Find a passage that makes Thea’s immediate objective clear: understanding someone, completing a task, or making a decision. Identify which concrete details place readers inside that objective rather than merely informing them about it.
15. Story Scenes, Summaries & Structures	Label a reading section as scene, summary, reflection, or a combination. Discuss why Stine might dramatize a consequential exchange while compressing repeated labor or the passage of difficult days.
16. Tension / Suspense / Surprise	Distinguish tension caused by environmental conditions from tension caused by unequal power within relationships. Identify what readers fear, what they do not yet know, and which expectations a passage unsettles.
17. Flashback, Flash-Forward, Cliffhanger	Check the assigned section for recollection, anticipation, or an unresolved ending, and label only devices actually present. Ask how information about Thea’s earlier life changes the meaning of her present circumstances.
18. Page Turns and Chapter Breaks	Inspect several chapter endings for a new question, withheld response, or changed emotional understanding. Use chapter boundaries rather than edition-specific page numbers when comparing findings.
19. Pace & Creativity	Rewrite a brief, nonquoted version of a homestead moment using a different ratio of action to reflection. Compare how the new pace changes the apparent importance of survival tasks and private thought.
20. Play	Look for moments when curiosity, ease, or connection interrupts the pressures surrounding Thea. If the selected passage contains none, write a clearly labeled invented interlude and consider whether it provides useful contrast or weakens the scene.
21. Performance	Present a short exchange through an accessible staged reading or annotated storyboard, tracking pauses, gaze, and who has access to each message. Do not imitate hearing loss or improvise supposedly authentic signs.
22. Personality	Identify a moment when Thea’s response could not be replaced by a generic teenager’s response without changing the scene. Explain how her particular priorities influence what the narration notices and how long it stays there.
23. Humor	Check for irony, understatement, or lighter interaction rather than assuming the novel uses frequent jokes. If humor appears, discuss whether it creates relief, establishes closeness, or exposes the gap between the family’s dream and reality.
24. Pause	Find a moment when external action slows while Thea observes or reassesses. Explain whether the pause offers safety, increases discomfort, or prepares a consequential choice.
25. Poetry / Poetic Devices	Examine a landscape passage for imagery, figurative language, or patterned phrasing, identifying devices only when supported by the text. Discuss how those choices make dust or dryness carry emotional significance without reducing the setting to a simple symbol.
26. Repetition	Track recurring references to dust, distance, and communication across the reading. Ask whether each recurrence reinforces an existing meaning or changes as Thea gains experience and connection.
27. Rhythm	Mark the sequence of short and long sentences in a chosen paragraph. Connect the pattern to the experience being narrated, such as repetitive work, watchful waiting, or an urgent realization.
28. Punctuation	Analyze the actual punctuation of a tense exchange or reflective paragraph. Try one alternative arrangement and explain how it changes hesitation, emphasis, or the reader’s processing time.
29. Questions	List questions Thea asks, questions she cannot comfortably ask, and questions readers carry forward. Discuss how an unanswered question about trust or independence can propel a scene without physical action.
30. Compare-Contrast	Compare the family’s ideal of self-sufficiency with the support Thea finds through connection. Study how alternating between those experiences changes the reader’s sense of possibility.
31. Objects	Select a concrete object actually present in the assigned passage, such as an item involved in work or communication. Trace how its use reveals dependence, access, control, or care rather than assigning it an unsupported symbolic meaning.
32. Threes	Search for an actual three-part phrase, sequence, or grouping in the excerpt; do not assume one is present. If absent, construct a three-detail revision of an original landscape description and evaluate its cumulative effect.
33. Lists	Look for accumulations of tasks, needs, or environmental details, whether formally listed or embedded in prose. Explain how accumulation can make homesteading feel exhausting even when the narrative covers time quickly.
34. White Space & Negative Space	Inspect paragraph and section breaks in the class edition for moments where readers must supply a transition or absorb a realization. Distinguish visible white space from figurative gaps in what characters communicate.
35. Art & Graphics	Treat the cover and any edition-specific design as paratext, not as evidence about events within the story. Create a visual pacing map showing how a selected passage moves between environmental pressure, interaction, and reflection.
36. Interactives & Gamification	As a classroom adaptation, create choice cards based on a dilemma Thea faces and require textual evidence for each proposed response. Do not score hearing access, disability, or environmental hardship as personal deficits or entertainment.
37. Placement	Examine where Stine places a significant environmental detail or piece of relationship information within a scene. Move it earlier or later in a paraphrased outline and discuss how the change affects anticipation and interpretation.
38. Form	Study how sustained prose fiction allows Thea’s external circumstances and private interpretations to develop together. Adapt a short moment into a script or visual sequence and identify what the new form gains and loses.
39. Dummy	Use 'dummy' in its publishing sense: a rough structural mock-up, here adapted into a six-panel scene storyboard. Allocate panels to setting, interaction, uncertainty, reflection, decision, and consequence to test the pacing of an original Dust-inspired scene.
40. Passion	Infer the novel’s central commitments from repeated attention to environmental vulnerability, communication access, and Thea’s autonomy. Ask students to identify a concern they genuinely care about and make it visible through a character’s specific choices rather than a concluding lecture.

Pace-Write It!

20-minute Pace-Write-It! task: 'One Decision, Two Speeds.' Before class, select a short passage in which Thea navigates a communication barrier or weighs connection against the isolation of the Colorado homestead. Minutes 0–4: Students reread and annotate one pacing shift, noting sentence length, paragraphing, sensory detail, or delayed information. Minutes 4–6: Briefly discuss how the passage locates the barrier—in the environment, another person’s behavior, or unequal access to information. Minutes 6–11: Students write an original 80–100-word scene in which a teenager in a dust-dry landscape decides whether to seek help from someone beyond their household; they use short action units to create urgency. Minutes 11–16: Students rewrite the same event in 80–100 words, slowing it with observation, reflection, and a purposeful pause while keeping the character’s available information consistent. Minutes 16–19: Partners compare versions and underline two choices that alter pace; sharing may be written rather than spoken. Minutes 19–20: Each writer completes: 'Like the passage from Dust, my revision uses ___ to make the reader experience ___.' These are original craft exercises, not invented passages presented as Stine’s text.

Classroom Activities

Dust, Distance, and the Right to Be Heard

Students build a visual pacing map of a short passage involving Thea’s isolation, communication, or experience of the Colorado environment. They then write the same original moment twice—once at an urgent pace and once at a reflective pace—to explore how sentence structure, sensory selection, and access to information influence a reader’s experience. The writing should focus on environmental or interpersonal barriers rather than treating hearing loss as a suspense gimmick.

Create a free account to reveal this guide

Your free account includes one complete guide download — the full teacher’s guide, discussion questions, classroom activities, and the Pace-Write-Read writing workshop.

Create Free Account Sign in

Discussion questions PWR workshop PDF download