Many Things under a Rock Young Readers Edition

by David Scheel, Laurel "Yoyo" Scheel

In this young readers adaptation, marine biologist David Scheel introduces readers to the surprising lives of octopuses through scientific investigation and personal encounters, including experiences shared with his daughter, Laurel “Yoyo” Scheel. This narrative nonfiction book explores octopus behavior, intelligence, and relationships while showing how curiosity and careful observation can change our understanding of another species.

Big Idea

Understanding another living creature begins with patient observation and a willingness to question assumptions. Writers can make scientific discoveries compelling by balancing vivid encounters, clear explanations, and honest uncertainty.

Discussion Questions

1.How do the encounters described in the book challenge the idea that an animal must behave like a human to be intelligent?
2.What do David and Yoyo gain from spending time observing octopuses that they might not learn from a list of facts?
3.Choose an observation from the book. What does it show directly, and what questions or possible explanations does it raise?
4.How does the book balance the excitement of meeting an octopus with explanations of the science behind its behavior?
5.After reading this book, what responsibilities do you think people have toward octopuses and their habitats? Which details influenced your thinking?

Lesson Plan

⏱ 50 minutes📦 Copies of the book or selected passages, paper, pencils, colored pencils or crayons, sticky notes, and a board or chart paper.

Learning Goals

Use details from the book to explain an aspect of octopus behavior.
Distinguish direct observations from interpretations and unanswered questions.
Organize a short nonfiction account with a clear sequence and purposeful pacing.
Revise sentence length, detail, and pauses to influence a reader’s experience.
Represent a real animal accurately without presenting imagined thoughts as scientific facts.

Activity Steps

1.Read a short passage describing an octopus encounter. Identify the setting, the observable actions, and any explanation the authors provide.
2.Create a class chart labeled Observed, Inferred, and Still Wondering. Sort details from the passage, recording a page number for supporting evidence.
3.Fold a sheet of paper into four panels labeled Encounter, Close Observation, Change or Discovery, and Explanation or Question. Plan one factual moment for each panel.
4.Write and illustrate the sequence. Use brief sentences to convey a sudden action and a longer, detail-rich sentence to slow down a moment of observation; do not add unsupported events.
5.Exchange sequences with a partner and read them aloud. Partners identify where the writing speeds up or slows down and flag any inference presented as a fact.
6.Revise one panel for pacing and one statement for accuracy, then share the completed sequence and its source passage.

Standards Connections

ELA: CCSS RI.3.1–RI.7.1 — Ask and answer questions, refer to details, and cite textual evidence; adjust expectations by grade.
ELA: CCSS W.3.2–W.7.2 — Write informative texts that develop a topic with relevant facts, details, and clear organization.
ELA: CCSS W.3.5–W.7.5 — Strengthen writing through planning, revising, and editing with appropriate support.
ELA: CCSS SL.3.1–SL.7.1 — Participate effectively in collaborative discussions.
Science: NGSS Science and Engineering Practices — Analyze observations, construct explanations, and communicate information; emphasize the distinction between evidence and interpretation.

Pace-Write-Read Study with Pace-Write It!

Many Things under a Rock Young Readers Edition offers a useful model for studying pacing in narrative nonfiction. Its subject is real, but readers still experience anticipation: What will an octopus do, and what might that behavior mean? David Scheel’s scientific perspective and the experiences shared with Yoyo invite students to see that a writer can create interest without inventing events. The central craft move is choosing when readers should watch an encounter closely and when they need an explanation to understand it. For a Pace-Write-Read study, pair a passage centered on an encounter with one centered on scientific explanation. Students can mark actions, sensory details, questions, and factual explanations, then listen to how those choices affect reading speed. Their goal is not simply to make writing faster: it is to give an important observation enough attention while keeping the larger inquiry moving. Treat this book as narrative nonfiction despite the supplied fiction label, and use the classroom edition to verify wording, illustrations, and page-specific features.

Element	How to notice or teach it in the novel
Pacing	Compare an octopus encounter with a passage that explains behavior. Ask where the reader seems to watch events unfold and where the writer moves across information more quickly.
Plot	Map an encounter as question, observation, response, and changed understanding. Explain that nonfiction can have a narrative arc without invented conflict or a neatly solved mystery.
Prosody	Read an encounter aloud, then read a scientific explanation aloud. Use phrasing, emphasis, and pauses to make both the action and the meaning clear rather than treating every sentence as equally dramatic.
Word	Collect precise verbs used for octopus movement and observation. Discuss how a specific verb can communicate more efficiently than a vague verb followed by several modifiers.
Concept	Trace how the book develops the idea of intelligence through observable behavior. Have students explain how an encounter makes an abstract scientific concept easier to understand.
Voice & Worldview	Notice how scientific curiosity shapes the way octopuses are presented. Ask students to identify language that invites respect for an animal whose way of experiencing the world differs from ours.
Point of View	Distinguish the human observer’s account from the octopus’s unknowable inner perspective. Discuss why an observed action does not automatically reveal what an animal thinks or feels.
Setting & Place	Track how the marine setting affects what observers can see and learn about octopuses. Identify details that make the habitat part of the investigation rather than merely a backdrop.
Original Characters	Treat David, Yoyo, and the octopuses as real participants rather than invented characters. Examine how selected actions and reactions make individuals memorable without requiring fabricated traits.
Dialogue	If a selected passage includes quoted speech, examine how it reveals a question or reaction more immediately than summary would. If it does not, discuss why a nonfiction writer should not invent dialogue to increase excitement.
Details	Choose a behavioral detail that supports an explanation about octopuses. Ask students what understanding would be lost if the writer removed it.
Descriptions	Examine descriptions of octopus appearance, movement, or surroundings in the assigned passage. Identify which details help readers visualize the encounter and which also supply scientific information.
Firsts	Locate a moment when an observer encounters something unfamiliar or revises an expectation. Discuss how presenting that discovery before its explanation lets readers experience some of the observer’s curiosity.
Immediacy & Engagement	Identify a passage that places readers close to an octopus’s actions. Explain how concrete actions and a clear observer’s position can create immediacy without exaggeration.
Story Scenes, Summaries & Structures	Color-code a selection for close-up scene, compressed summary, and scientific explanation. Discuss how each mode serves a different purpose in telling the story of studying octopuses.
Tension / Suspense / Surprise	Look for a gap between what an observer expects and what an octopus actually does. Show how uncertainty about an animal’s next action or the meaning of its behavior can create nonfiction suspense.
Flashback, Flash-Forward, Cliffhanger	Check whether a chosen section looks back to an earlier experience, anticipates later understanding, or ends with an unresolved question. Name only the devices actually present and explain their effects on the investigation’s timeline.
Page Turns and Chapter Breaks	Inspect a chapter ending in the classroom edition and ask what encourages continued reading: a question, discovery, or new direction. Distinguish a deliberate chapter boundary from a page turn caused by typesetting.
Pace & Creativity	Rewrite a brief, sourced observation in two versions: one concise and one slowed by accurate details. Compare the effects while keeping the underlying event unchanged.
Play	When discussing behavior that seems playful, separate the visible action from the label people give it. Invite students to ask what additional evidence would support interpreting that behavior as play.
Performance	Have pairs perform a passage as a narrator and an evidence-checker, with the second reader identifying observations and interpretations afterward. Use vocal emphasis to highlight discoveries without adding fictional speech.
Personality	Discuss how repeated observations can lead people to describe individual octopuses differently. Ask which actions support a personality description and where the description remains an interpretation.
Humor	If students find an encounter amusing, identify whether the humor comes from surprise, human expectations, or the telling. Discuss how amusement can invite interest without making the animal merely a comic prop.
Pause	Find a place where an action gives way to reflection or explanation. Read it with a deliberate pause and discuss how that moment allows readers to reconsider what they have just observed.
Poetry / Poetic Devices	Look for figurative or sensory language in a description of octopus life. Discuss how a comparison can clarify an unfamiliar animal while also having limits as a scientific explanation.
Repetition	Track a recurring question or idea about octopus behavior across selected passages. Ask how returning to it with new evidence develops understanding rather than simply repeating information.
Rhythm	Compare the sentence patterns in an action-focused passage and an explanatory passage. Read both aloud to explore how changes in sentence length and structure influence momentum.
Punctuation	Choose sentences from an encounter and examine how their actual punctuation groups actions or explanations. Test different oral pauses while retaining the printed words, then discuss which reading best communicates the meaning.
Questions	Collect questions the book raises about octopuses and sort them into answered, partly answered, and still open. Discuss how unanswered questions can sustain curiosity without making the nonfiction account incomplete.
Compare-Contrast	Identify a comparison involving human and octopus behavior or different observations of octopuses. Ask how comparison helps readers understand difference without assuming that similar actions have identical causes.
Objects	Select a concrete feature or object from a documented encounter, such as a rock or shelter when present. Trace how it helps readers follow the octopus’s actions and understand the setting.
Threes	Check a passage for an actual three-part sequence or grouping and discuss its effect if one appears. As a transfer exercise, students can organize three accurate observations from the book into a concise sequence.
Lists	Find a passage that groups facts, behaviors, or examples and compare it with a scene focused on one event. Discuss how grouping information changes the amount readers learn in a short space.
White Space & Negative Space	Inspect paragraph breaks and any other visible spacing in the classroom edition. Ask how these spaces separate an encounter from an explanation or give readers time to absorb a new idea.
Art & Graphics	If the edition includes photographs, illustrations, or diagrams, pair one with its related text. Identify what the visual communicates directly and what still requires explanation or a caption.
Interactives & Gamification	Create a classroom evidence hunt rather than assuming the book contains game features. Teams locate a behavioral observation, a scientific explanation, and an unresolved question, earning credit for accurate sourcing and reasoning.
Placement	Examine where an explanation appears relative to the encounter it helps interpret. Discuss how placing information before an event prepares readers, while placing it afterward can preserve discovery.
Form	Identify features of narrative nonfiction: real participants, documented events, factual explanation, and a shaped reading experience. Discuss why these features fit this account of octopus research better than a fiction label.
Dummy	Make a four-panel paper dummy, or rough layout, of a sourced octopus encounter. Move the observation, illustration, explanation, and question between panels to test how layout changes the reader’s experience.
Passion	Look for evidence of sustained curiosity in David’s research and the experiences shared with Yoyo. Discuss how attention to a subject can make informational writing engaging while still requiring careful evidence.

Pace-Write It!

20-minute Pace-Write-It! task: An Octopus Moment, Two Speeds. Minutes 0–3: Reread a short, teacher-selected encounter from the book and identify one documented action and one supporting detail. Minutes 3–6: Record what is directly observed, what is interpreted, and the source page. Minutes 6–11: Write a 60–90-word account that slows down the observation using precise, supported details. Minutes 11–15: Rewrite the same event in 30–45 words, using concise sentences to move more quickly without changing the facts. Minutes 15–18: Partners read both versions aloud and identify which choices change the pace. Minutes 18–20: Each writer selects the version that best serves the encounter and adds a one-sentence explanation of that choice. For younger writers, use shorter targets or allow dictation; do not invent octopus thoughts, dialogue, or actions.

Classroom Activities

Under the Rock: Observe, Wonder, Reveal

Students turn a documented octopus encounter from the book into a short, illustrated nonfiction sequence. Using movable paper panels, they reveal an observation, slow down an important moment, and finish with an evidence-based explanation or an unanswered question. The activity makes pacing visible while reinforcing the distinction between what an observer sees and what an observer infers.

Create a free account to reveal this guide

Your free account includes one complete guide download — the full teacher’s guide, discussion questions, classroom activities, and the Pace-Write-Read writing workshop.

Create Free Account Sign in

Discussion questions PWR workshop PDF download